What specific elements of the American Eagle ad campaign featuring Sydney Sweeney have been criticized as promoting racist or eugenic themes?

The ad campaign has been criticized for its pun on 'great genes' versus 'great jeans,' close-up shots of Sydney Sweeney's blue eyes, and slogans that some interpret as echoing language linked to Nazi propaganda and eugenics.

Why has the campaign been described as tone-deaf and even labeled 'Nazi' by some critics?

Critics argue the campaign's use of genetic language and visual elements suggests an endorsement of whiteness and eugenics, themes historically associated with Nazi ideology, leading to accusations of tone-deafness and inappropriate messaging.

Has American Eagle or Sydney Sweeney responded to the controversy surrounding the ad campaign?

As of now, neither Sydney Sweeney nor American Eagle has publicly responded to the backlash against the ad campaign.

What is the intended message or purpose behind the American Eagle campaign featuring Sydney Sweeney?

The campaign promotes a limited-edition denim line called 'The Sydney Jean' and aims to celebrate American style with Sydney Sweeney featured prominently, including an emphasis on comfort and style with slogans like 'Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.' Proceeds benefit mental health support.

What broader cultural or societal debates does this controversy touch upon regarding advertising and marketing?

The controversy highlights ongoing discussions about the role of advertising in shaping cultural narratives, the responsibility of brands to avoid promoting regressive or exclusionary ideologies, and sensitivity towards historical contexts such as racism and eugenics in marketing messages.

9 articles

·17d

American Eagle Ad Campaign Featuring Sydney Sweeney Sparks Controversy

Sydney Sweeney's new American Eagle denim ad campaign has drawn significant criticism, with an MSNBC op-ed and other critics accusing it of promoting racist, regressive themes, "Whiteness," and "eugenics."

l 11%

r 89%

CLARK BARRON: Liberals Can't Handle Sydney Sweeney In Jeans — Now Everyone Wants To Buy Them

Daily Caller

Liberal Commentators Decry American Eagle for Promoting ‘White Supremacy’ With New Sydney Sweeney ‘Good Jeans’ Campaign

New York Sun

Liberal media outlets argue Sydney Sweeney ‘Good Jeans’ ad promoting ‘Whiteness,’ ‘eugenics’

FOX News

'Good Morning America' Has Most Ridiculous Response To Sydney Sweeney's New Ad Campaign

Daily Caller

MSNBC Producer Lashes Out at American Eagle's Sydney Sweeney Ads: 'Regressive... Shift Toward Whiteness'

Western Journal

Leftists freak out over alleged ‘Nazi propaganda’ in American Eagle jeans ad featuring Sydney Sweeney

The Post Millennial

Critics Attack Sydney Sweeney Over New Endorsement Ad. Everyone's Missing Big Picture

Daily Caller

American Eagle faces backlash over ‘Sydney Sweeney has great jeans’ ad

The Guardian

Leftists Crash Out Over ‘Whiteness’ Of Sexy Sydney Sweeney Jean Ads

The Daily Wire

Overview

A summary of the key points of this story verified across multiple sources.

Sydney Sweeney's new American Eagle denim ad campaign has ignited controversy, facing criticism for allegedly promoting racist and regressive themes.
Critics argue the campaign, featuring Sweeney, reflects a concerning cultural shift towards capitalist exploitation by promoting "Whiteness" and "eugenics."
An MSNBC op-ed specifically criticized the American Eagle ads, labeling them "ugly and startling" due to their perceived promotion of a cultural shift towards whiteness.
The backlash centers on the ad's perceived messaging, with accusations that it subtly endorses problematic ideologies through its visual content.
The controversy highlights ongoing debates about advertising's role in cultural narratives and the responsibility of brands in their marketing campaigns.

Written by AI using shared reports from

9 articles

Report issue

Read both sides in 5 minutes each day

Analysis

Compare how each side frames the story — including which facts they emphasize or leave out.

Analysis unavailable for this viewpoint.

Right-leaning sources frame this story by portraying "leftist" reactions to the American Eagle ad as irrational and extreme. They use dismissive language to characterize concerns about "good genes" and eugenics as an overreaction, emphasizing the "blonde bombshell" aspect of Sydney Sweeney and mocking those who raise "Nazi" or "fasc-y coded" allegations.

"The jeans sold out, and according to Business Insider, American Eagle’s stock saw a 12% spike the week of the campaign’s release."

Daily Caller

·17d

Article

"The advertisement — which centers around a conventionally attractive white woman with blonde hair, blue eyes, and a slim build and incorporates quintessential Americana imagery — represents a marked shift from American Eagle’s past campaigns, which tended to emphasize physical and racial diversity."

New York Sun

·17d

Fully paywalled — this outlets requires a subscription or login.

Article

"Despite the jeans promoting a good cause, online critics were fixated on the ad’s alleged White supremacist undertones."

FOX News

·17d

Article

"But still, a seemingly milquetoast program like “Good Morning America” wading into Sydney Sweeney ad discourse by comparing it to Nazi propaganda is absurd, even for ABC News’ standards."

Daily Caller

·17d

Article

"Holland isn’t just delusional, but her argument is insulting to the intelligence of average Americans."

Western Journal

·17d

Article

"The TikTokers and social media denizens all stare into their cameras agog that the joke would be made, that Sweeney has blue eyes and blonde hair, and claim that the ads are not just for jeans, but for Nazis."

The Post Millennial

·17d

Article

"The advertisement was perfectly cast and created, and the overly sensitive viewers who are reading too much into this need to do their homework."

Daily Caller

·17d

Article

"The internet has been quick to condemn the advertisement as noninclusive at best and as overtly promoting ‘white supremacy’ and ‘Nazi propaganda’ at worst."

The Daily Wire

·17d

Limited access — this outlet restricts by article count and/or content type.

Article

How we categorize media bias

Articles (9)

Compare how different news outlets are covering this story.

Sort By

Center (0)

No articles found in the Center category

FAQ

Dig deeper on this story with frequently asked questions.

: The ad campaign has been criticized for its pun on 'great genes' versus 'great jeans,' close-up shots of Sydney Sweeney's blue eyes, and slogans that some interpret as echoing language linked to Nazi propaganda and eugenics.
Euronews
: Critics argue the campaign's use of genetic language and visual elements suggests an endorsement of whiteness and eugenics, themes historically associated with Nazi ideology, leading to accusations of tone-deafness and inappropriate messaging.
Euronews
: As of now, neither Sydney Sweeney nor American Eagle has publicly responded to the backlash against the ad campaign.
Firstpost YouTube
: The campaign promotes a limited-edition denim line called 'The Sydney Jean' and aims to celebrate American style with Sydney Sweeney featured prominently, including an emphasis on comfort and style with slogans like 'Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.' Proceeds benefit mental health support.
Firstpost YouTube
: The controversy highlights ongoing discussions about the role of advertising in shaping cultural narratives, the responsibility of brands to avoid promoting regressive or exclusionary ideologies, and sensitivity towards historical contexts such as racism and eugenics in marketing messages.
Euronews

History

See how this story has evolved over time.

This story does not have any previous versions.