Cracker Barrel Reverts to Original Branding After Rebranding Backlash and Customer Traffic Decline
Cracker Barrel abandoned its CEO-led rebranding, including a new logo, after customer backlash and a 16% traffic drop. The company returned to its original branding, pleasing investors and causing an 8% stock rise.
Cracker Barrel rolls over and surrenders to right-wing attacks
Chicago Sun-Times
Cracker Barrel’s Logo Was Never the Problem
The Atlantic
Subscribe to unlock this story
We really don't like cutting you off, but you've reached your monthly limit. At just $5/month, subscriptions are how we keep this project going. Start your free 7-day trial today!
Get StartedHave an account? Sign in
Overview
- Cracker Barrel hired CEO Masino in 2023 to lead a rebranding initiative aimed at attracting new customers and revitalizing the brand's image.
- The rebranding effort, which included a controversial new logo, backfired significantly, resulting in a 16% decrease in customer traffic compared to 2019 levels.
- Facing backlash and confusion from customers, Cracker Barrel publicly apologized and decided to return to its original, beloved branding and logo.
- Despite the customer traffic decline, Cracker Barrel reported its fourth consecutive quarter of same-store sales growth during its fiscal third quarter.
- Investors reacted positively to Cracker Barrel's strategic adjustments, causing the company's stock to rise 8% upon news of returning to its original branding.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources frame this story as Cracker Barrel's "capitulation" to "perpetually-offended right-wing woke police." They use loaded language like "insufferable whiners" and "total surrender" to portray the company's decision as a sad, pathetic, yet strategically smart move driven by fear of "MAGA" boycotts, rather than a response to genuine customer feedback.
"Cracker Barrel learned that the only way to survive in the strongarm era of Trump, where a vocal group of insufferable whiners is going to decide how the rest of us live, is total surrender."
Chicago Sun-Times"The old man is now back in his rightful place, welcoming the tired and the hungry to a roadside oasis."
USA TODAY"Cracker Barrel's rebranding failure is a sign of the times."
Business Insider"Cracker Barrel acknowledged Monday that it should have done a better job with the new logo's rollout."
ABC NewsArticles (16)
Center (4)
FAQ
Cracker Barrel reverted to its original branding due to significant customer backlash and a 16% decline in customer traffic following the new logo and rebranding effort, which customers found generic and disconnected from the company's legacy. The company publicly apologized and acknowledged the mistake, deciding to restore the beloved original logo to honor their brand's roots.
The rebranding included a new text-only logo that removed the iconic image of a man leaning over a barrel, which had been part of the logo since 1977. Customers and branding experts criticized the new design as generic and lacking the story and emotional connection embodied in the previous logo's imagery.
Investors responded positively, with the company's stock price rising by 8% following the announcement of returning to the original branding, reflecting confidence in the company's strategic adjustment.
Despite the decline in customer traffic due to the rebranding, Cracker Barrel reported its fourth consecutive quarter of same-store sales growth during its fiscal third quarter, indicating solid financial performance in certain metrics.
History
- 20d4 articles
