Federal Judge Orders Dr. Phil's Merit Street Media into Chapter 7 Liquidation Amid Allegations of Wrongdoing
Dr. Phil McGraw's Merit Street Media faces Chapter 7 liquidation by a federal judge, who rejected its Chapter 11 filing due to alleged wrongdoing, favoritism, and deleted incriminating messages.
Subscribe to unlock this story
We really don't like cutting you off, but you've reached your monthly limit. At just $5/month, subscriptions are how we keep this project going. Start your free 7-day trial today!
Get StartedHave an account? Sign in
Overview
- Dr. Phil McGraw's media company, Merit Street Media, has been ordered by a federal bankruptcy judge to undergo Chapter 7 liquidation, rather than its requested Chapter 11 filing.
- Judge Scott Everett rejected Merit Street's Chapter 11 petition, citing significant concerns over alleged favoritism towards specific creditors and a lack of transparency in its business operations.
- The court revealed that Dr. Phil McGraw deleted incriminating text messages, which reportedly outlined a strategy to deliberately avoid paying creditors through the bankruptcy process.
- The judge's decision to force Chapter 7 liquidation stems from these serious allegations of wrongdoing and a perceived lack of good faith in the company's financial dealings.
- Amidst these bankruptcy proceedings, Merit Street Media is also actively pursuing a lawsuit against Trinity Broadcasting, alleging a breach of contract.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources cover the story neutrally by presenting the facts of the bankruptcy proceedings without injecting editorial bias. They attribute all strong claims and evaluative language to court documents, the judge, or the involved parties, ensuring the narrative remains objective and balanced by including Dr. Phil's denials.
"A northern Texas judge ruled that Dr. Phil McGraw's Merit Street Media company assets will undergo a Chapter 7 liquidation instead of a Chapter 11 reorganization due to concerns of alleged wrongdoing."
USA TODAYArticles (3)
FAQ
The judge ordered Chapter 7 liquidation because of serious concerns about alleged wrongdoing, including favoritism towards certain creditors, lack of transparency, and deleted incriminating messages that suggested a strategy to avoid paying creditors. He believed Chapter 7, with a trustee handling asset sales, would ensure a fair outcome for all creditors, unlike Chapter 11 which could allow Merit's control to favor preferred creditors.
Merit Street Media sued TBN for breach of contract, alleging TBN failed to provide promised free nationwide carriage and production services, causing Merit Street to incur approximately $96 million in carriage costs. Trinity Broadcasting Network, which held a controlling stake, countersued McGraw for fraud, leading to a complex legal battle tied to control of Merit Street Media.
Peteski Productions, Dr. Phil’s production company, provided significant financial support by injecting $25 million in debt earlier and committing up to $21.4 million in debtor-in-possession financing to aid Merit Street’s Chapter 11 proceedings. Peteski is also listed as a creditor owed $700,000 and is actively involved in helping restructure Merit Street's finances.
The judge criticized Dr. Phil for retaining control of Merit Street Media during bankruptcy and allegedly favoring selected creditors, while undermining others like TBN and PBR. The judge noted the unusual situation of a debtor hiring away employees and launching a new media company to absorb assets during bankruptcy, reflecting a lack of good faith and transparency.
Merit Street Media is actively pursuing a lawsuit against TBN for breach of contract, claiming TBN failed to meet distribution and production commitments, which caused substantial financial damage. The lawsuit is part of the ongoing bankruptcy and legal disputes concerning control and creditor repayments.
History
- This story does not have any previous versions.