Pano News
Subscribe
Crime

Alex Murdaugh Returns To Court

A judge urged lawyers to resolve evidence fights before Alex Murdaugh’s murder retrial.

October 16, 2026 · Updated Oct 16, 4:38pm ET

33%

Left · 3

45%

Center · 4

22%

Right · 2

Pano counted 9 articles from 9 outlets: 33% left-leaning, 45% center and 22% right-leaning. Pano rates the coverage Balanced.

What happened

Judge Debra McCaslin allowed Alex Murdaugh’s defense to test DNA found under Maggie Murdaugh’s fingernails, even though the testing could consume the sample. She denied the defense’s request for ballistics information and evidence from other local shootings, calling it a fishing expedition. Murdaugh is accused of killing his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, at their Colleton County home in June 2021. He has denied the murders. South Carolina’s high court overturned his 2023 convictions after finding court clerk Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors. Murdaugh remains imprisoned for financial crimes. The defense accused prosecutors of poor evidence sharing, while prosecutors called the disputes misunderstandings. His retrial is scheduled for April 5, 2027.

How the left told it

Left-leaning outlets framed the hearing as a preparation fight, with more focus on disclosure and courtroom fairness than on dramatic alternative theories. Los Angeles Times centered Murdaugh’s lawyers saying prosecutors were “dragging their feet” on evidence. CNN highlighted questions about whether local police may have handled the missing weapons, a point tied to challenging the lone-killer theory.

How the right told it

Right-leaning outlets cast the hearing as a search for evidence that could shift blame, giving more weight to the defense’s alternative-killer claims. Daily Mail emphasized lawyers’ request for information they believe could point to another killer and described an “explosive claim” involving a violent street gang. World News Group stressed the impartial-jury safeguard after improper influence tainted the original conviction.

Topics in this story