O.J. Simpson Case Reexamined
A Times investigation revisits the 1994 murders and claims about a weapon and possible accomplice.
October 18, 2026 · Updated Oct 18, 9:09pm ET
80%
Left · 8
0%
Center · 0
20%
Right · 2
Pano counted 10 articles from 6 outlets: 80% left-leaning, 0% center and 20% right-leaning. Pano rates the coverage Mostly Left.
What happened
Newly unsealed federal court records show that mob-connected drug trafficker and informant Joseph “Joey” Ippolito told authorities he had information about O.J. Simpson’s alleged disposal of the murder weapon and efforts to avoid prosecution. The information reached Los Angeles prosecutors after they had rested their murder case, and Ippolito was not called to testify. Ippolito was a friend of Simpson confidant Al Cowlings, and prosecutors had called him highly reliable in other investigations. Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman were murdered in 1994; Simpson was acquitted, later found civilly liable, and the weapon was never found. Sam Ippolito said Joey returned with bloody hands and a heavy bag, while a tenant’s lawyer called that absurd. No new forensic evidence has emerged.
How the left told it
Left-leaning outlets treated the records as a challenge to the lone-killer narrative, stressing the possibility of outside help rather than closing the case. The New York Times framed Simpson’s supposedly hypothetical account of receiving help as newly worthy of scrutiny. It also placed the case inside America’s lasting fascination with celebrity, violence and true crime.
How the right told it
Right-leaning outlets led with newly unsealed records and unresolved questions around Simpson’s trial. Fox News, quoting The New York Times, framed the revelations as raising the possibility that a mob-connected associate helped cover up the murders, with the brother’s bloody-hands account adding a darker dimension. Newsmax reported that authorities had received information about the missing murder weapon, reopening questions about what was known at trial, while noting David Kelley’s doubt that Ippolito took part in the killings.

The New York Times
FOX News
Boston Globe


Daily Beast