Heated Exchange on MS-13 Allegations: Swalwell Grills Noem Over Photo of Deportee
Rep. Eric Swalwell confronts Sec. Kristi Noem during a budget hearing over the authenticity of a photo used to justify Kilmar Abrego Garcia's deportation.
Noem refuses to answer whether picture of Kilmar Abrego Garcia was doctored
Washington Examiner
Overview
During a tense House Homeland Security Committee hearing, Rep. Eric Swalwell challenged Secretary Kristi Noem regarding the authenticity of a photo related to deportee Kilmar Abrego Garcia, allegedly altered to depict MS-13 tattoos. Noem evaded confirming if the image was doctored, focusing instead on national security issues. The exchange highlighted ongoing debates over the Trump administration's immigration policies and the accuracy of claims connecting Garcia to gang affiliations. Legal advocacy surrounding Garcia's case continues amidst claims of due process violations.
Content generated by AI—learn more or report issue.
Get both sides in 5 minutes with our daily newsletter.
Analysis
Left
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem faced harsh questioning from Democrats regarding her handling of deportations, especially concerning Kilmar Abrego Garcia, whose due process rights were allegedly violated, leading to a Supreme Court ruling against the administration's actions.
Democrats criticized Noem for misleading claims about Abrego Garcia being a terrorist and for arguing that deported citizen children were taken under appropriate circumstances, despite contradicting statements from family attorneys and lawmakers.
The hearing also highlighted broader concerns about the Trump administration's approach to immigration enforcement, with calls for more accountability and adherence to judicial rulings.
Center
There are not enough sources from this perspective to provide an analysis.
Right
Kristi Noem defended the deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, asserting that he is a known member of MS-13 and a criminal, emphasizing her focus on national security over the alleged fabrication of a controversial photo used to label Garcia as a gang member.
Republican lawmakers, including Noem, expressed frustration with Democratic representatives who defended Abrego Garcia, characterizing their support as misplaced and detrimental to U.S. safety.
Noem and fellow Republicans reiterated that Abrego Garcia's deportation followed legal protocols and standing judicial orders, maintaining that he should not return to the U.S. due to his criminal ties.
Left
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem faced harsh questioning from Democrats regarding her handling of deportations, especially concerning Kilmar Abrego Garcia, whose due process rights were allegedly violated, leading to a Supreme Court ruling against the administration's actions.
Democrats criticized Noem for misleading claims about Abrego Garcia being a terrorist and for arguing that deported citizen children were taken under appropriate circumstances, despite contradicting statements from family attorneys and lawmakers.
The hearing also highlighted broader concerns about the Trump administration's approach to immigration enforcement, with calls for more accountability and adherence to judicial rulings.
Center
There are not enough sources from this perspective to provide an analysis.
Right
Kristi Noem defended the deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, asserting that he is a known member of MS-13 and a criminal, emphasizing her focus on national security over the alleged fabrication of a controversial photo used to label Garcia as a gang member.
Republican lawmakers, including Noem, expressed frustration with Democratic representatives who defended Abrego Garcia, characterizing their support as misplaced and detrimental to U.S. safety.
Noem and fellow Republicans reiterated that Abrego Garcia's deportation followed legal protocols and standing judicial orders, maintaining that he should not return to the U.S. due to his criminal ties.
Articles (6)
Rolling Stone·1M·No highlight available for this article.
FOX News·1M·No highlight available for this article.
Washington Examiner·1M·No highlight available for this article.
The Daily Wire·1M·No highlight available for this article.
Breitbart News·1M·No highlight available for this article.
Daily Caller·1M·No highlight available for this article.