US Navy to Rename USNS Harvey Milk Amid Controversy and Criticism
The US Navy's decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk has sparked backlash from activists and public figures, including Sean Penn and Dustin Lance Black.
Overview
The US Navy will rename the USNS Harvey Milk, named after the gay rights activist and Navy veteran, following an order from Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth. This decision, part of a broader initiative to align military assets with the current administration's values, has drawn significant criticism from leaders like former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and California Governor Gavin Newsom, who argue it erases civil rights history. Activists, including Milk's nephew, Stuart Milk, and figures like Sean Penn and Dustin Lance Black, have condemned the move as a politically motivated distraction. The renaming, expected to be finalized soon, comes during Pride Month and reflects ongoing cultural shifts within the military.
Content generated by AI—learn more or report issue.
Get both sides in 5 minutes with our daily newsletter.
Analysis
Left
The articles express strong disapproval of the decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk, viewing it as politically motivated.
Critics argue this action undermines LGBTQ+ rights and erases important civil rights history, especially during Pride Month.
The sentiment reflects a broader concern about attacks on diversity and inclusion in contemporary politics.
Center
The articles express strong discontent over the Trump administration's decision to remove Harvey Milk's name from a Navy ship.
Critics view the renaming as an attack on LGBTQ+ rights and a broader agenda against diversity and inclusion.
The timing during Pride Month amplifies the outrage and highlights the significance of Milk's legacy in civil rights.
Right
The articles express strong discontent over the Navy's decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk during Pride Month.
Critics, including Nancy Pelosi, argue the renaming erases LGBTQ history and undermines diversity in the military.
The decision has sparked significant backlash, reflecting a divisive atmosphere surrounding LGBTQ+ rights and military culture.
Left
The articles express strong disapproval of the decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk, viewing it as politically motivated.
Critics argue this action undermines LGBTQ+ rights and erases important civil rights history, especially during Pride Month.
The sentiment reflects a broader concern about attacks on diversity and inclusion in contemporary politics.
Center
The articles express strong discontent over the Trump administration's decision to remove Harvey Milk's name from a Navy ship.
Critics view the renaming as an attack on LGBTQ+ rights and a broader agenda against diversity and inclusion.
The timing during Pride Month amplifies the outrage and highlights the significance of Milk's legacy in civil rights.
Right
The articles express strong discontent over the Navy's decision to rename the USNS Harvey Milk during Pride Month.
Critics, including Nancy Pelosi, argue the renaming erases LGBTQ history and undermines diversity in the military.
The decision has sparked significant backlash, reflecting a divisive atmosphere surrounding LGBTQ+ rights and military culture.
Articles (20)
MSNBC·13d·"…Hegseth, evidently, is prioritizing his culture war agenda over Navy traditions."
Salon·13d·"…The renaming is expected to become official next week."
Rolling Stone·13d·"…Now, civil rights heroes will have their names scrubbed from Navy vessels, lest any seaman learn too much about the men and women who fought for the rights they may now enjoy."
The Guardian·12d·"…The renaming is supposed to ensure 'alignment with president and SECDEF objectives and SECNAV priorities of reestablishing the warrior culture', referring to Donald Trump, Hegseth and navy secretary John Phelan, according to the memorandum."
The Guardian·13d·"…The reported decision by the Trump administration to change the names of the USNS Harvey Milk and other ships in the John Lewis-class is a shameful, vindictive erasure of those who fought to break down barriers for all to chase the American dream."
Boston Globe·13d·"…It marks the latest move by Hegseth and the wider Trump administration to purge all programs, policies, books and social media mentions of references to diversity, equity and inclusion."
CNN·12d·"…The move also comes amid the administration’s broader efforts to eliminate diversity, equity and inclusion efforts in government and education."
NBC News·13d·"…The USNS Harvey Milk, a fleet replenishment oiler, will be renamed."
USA TODAY·12d·"…Announcing that you’re stripping the name of a gay rights activist from a Navy ship at the start of Pride Month is, of course, a transparent provocation."
Associated Press·12d·"…Leaders in San Francisco are blasting the Trump administration for stripping the name of gay rights activist Harvey Milk from a U.S. naval ship, and especially during Pride Month, when people gather to celebrate the LGBTQ+ community."
Associated Press·13d·"…It marks the latest move by Hegseth and the wider Trump administration to purge all programs, policies, books and social media mentions of references to diversity, equity and inclusion."
Military Times·13d·"…It marks the latest move by Hegseth and the wider Trump administration to purge all programs, policies, books and social media mentions of references to diversity, equity and inclusion."
World News Group·12d·"…The decision, which came as some Americans celebrate Pride Month, was characterized as shameful and vindictive."
FOX News·13d·"…The renaming has been soundly condemned by Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., who called the move a "shameful, vindictive erasure of those who fought to break down barriers for all to chase the American Dream.""
Washington Examiner·13d·"…The decision, which coincides with Pride Month, is the latest example of the secretary’s efforts to dismantle the department’s diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts by removing related programs, policies, positions, books, and social media posts."
The Daily Wire·13d·"…The U.S. Army announced that it had already surpassed recruiting goals for the entire year, four full months ahead of schedule."
The Blaze·13d·"…The reported decision by the Trump administration to change the names of the USNS Harvey Milk and other ships in the John Lewis-class is a shameful, vindictive erasure of those who fought to break down barriers for all to chase the American dream."
Newsmax·12d·"…Hegseth's timing to rename the ship occurred during Pride month, which was intentional, according to a defense official who spoke with Military.com."
Newsmax·12d·"…Hegseth's timing to rename the ship occurred during Pride month, which was intentional, according to a defense official who spoke with Military.com."
Breitbart News·13d·"…Several Democrats such as Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), and Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE), responded to the news by describing the move as being 'spiteful,' while others pointed out that Milk was a 'pedophile.'"
FAQ
History
- 12d19 articles
- 13d13 articles
- 13d10 articles