


Supreme Court Upholds Tennessee's Gender-Affirming Care Ban Amidst Controversy
The U.S. Supreme Court's 6-3 ruling on Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming care for minors has ignited debate over transgender rights and healthcare access.

The Supreme Court’s Cruel Alternative Reality for Trans People

New York Magazine

How Supreme Court Trans Health Care Ruling Will Affect Kids

Scientific American

Supreme Court Upholds Gender-Affirming-Care Ban

TIME Magazine

Supreme Court Upholds Tennessee Ban on Puberty Blockers for Minors

Washington Free Beacon

SCOTUS: State law against trans hormones for minors can stay

World News Group

BREAKING: Supreme Court upholds Tennessee’s ban on child sex changes

The Post Millennial
Subscribe to unlock this story
We really don't like cutting you off, but you've reached your monthly limit. At just $5/month, subscriptions are how we keep this project going. Start your free 7-day trial today!
Get StartedHave an account? Sign in
Overview
- The Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's ban on gender-affirming care for minors in a 6-3 decision, impacting similar laws across the U.S.
- Justice Clarence Thomas expressed concerns over the speed of medical treatments for children and questioned the evidence supporting gender interventions.
- Dissenting Justice Sonia Sotomayor argued that the ruling could cause harm to transgender children, reflecting a divide among justices.
- The decision has drawn mixed reactions from family groups, with some supporting the ruling and others voicing concerns for transgender youth.
- The ruling intensifies the ongoing debate over transgender rights and healthcare access, highlighting a divided public opinion and political landscape.
Report issue

Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Left-leaning sources often frame narratives through a lens of social justice, emphasizing equity and systemic critique. They tend to highlight marginalized voices, challenge traditional power structures, and advocate for progressive change, reflecting a bias towards inclusivity and reform while critiquing perceived injustices in societal norms and policies.
"The court's decision has left transgender children and their parents uncertain and anxious about the future."

"All queer people – and all cis women who aspire to be free – have had their dignity demeaned as a result."

"Roberts appeared to try to lower the temperature on the combustible issue of trans rights."

"The ruling is a huge setback for trans rights across the country."

"His decision for the court, handed down on Wednesday, is an incoherent mess of contradiction and casuistry, a travesty of legal writing that injects immense, gratuitous confusion into the law of equal protection."

"the Roberts Court’s decision in Skrmetti, which effectively bans gender-affirming care for trans minors in more than 20 states."

"There is nothing good to say about the hash of opinions from the conservative justices."

"The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld Tennessee’s ban on gender-affirming surgery for transgender youth in a ruling that’s likely to reverberate across the country."

"The Supreme Court delivered a brutal blow to transgender equality, upholding a Tennessee law that outlaws gender-affirming care for trans youth."

"The ruling is a major blow to transgender Americans’ rights and protections, which have been under attack at the state and federal level."

"The conservative Supreme Court dealt a significant blow to transgender Americans on Wednesday, issuing a sweeping decision that may have implications beyond the medical care that was at center of one of the court’s highest-profile disputes this year."

"The Supreme Court's decision sets a precedent for the 25 states that have bans on pediatric gender-affirming care, which many view as a retreat from meaningful judicial review and a failure to protect transgender children."

"The Supreme Court has delivered a major blow to transgender rights with its decision to uphold a Tennessee law that bars doctors from providing gender-affirming care including puberty blockers, hormones, and surgical procedures for trans minors in the state."

"The decision left Meredithe McNamara, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Yale School of Medicine who specializes in adolescent medicine, “devastated and scared”."

"The ruling in U.S. v. Skrmetti dictates that state laws prohibiting gender-affirming hormone therapies and puberty-pausing medications for transgender youth are constitutional."

"if her reasoning is adopted by a majority of the court in the future, it could further weaken transgender rights."

"The Supreme Court's decision is a devastating loss for transgender people, our families, and everyone who cares about the Constitution."

"The Court’s Republicans, in other words, could have applied existing law, sent the case back down to the lower courts to apply this “heightened scrutiny,” and then ruled on the bans in a future case."

"Today’s Supreme Court decision is a devastating blow to transgender youth and the families who love them."

"A Tennessee state law banning gender-affirming care for minors can stand, the US supreme court has ruled, a devastating loss for trans rights supporters in a case that could set a precedent for dozens of other lawsuits involving the rights of transgender children."

"The ruling, led by the court’s conservatives, is a major loss for the transgender community at an extremely vulnerable moment."

"The decision was fractured among the justices, with many writing independently, though all three liberals dissented."

"a stunning setback to transgender rights."

"The Supreme Court has upheld Tennessee’s ban on gender-affirming care for minors, in an opinion by Chief Justice John Roberts over dissent from the court’s Democratic appointees."

"The Supreme Court's ruling is a major blow to the transgender community and its advocates at a critical time."

Analysis unavailable for this viewpoint.
Right-leaning sources frame the Supreme Court's decisions on youth transgender treatments as protective, emphasizing concerns over medical ethics and the lack of evidence for gender interventions. They portray dissenting views as alarmist, suggesting a bias against expert consensus. The overall tone reflects a commitment to traditional values and skepticism towards progressive ideologies.
"In the case of child sex changes, experts relied on poorly done studies and the word of "expert" activists rather than common sense about what's best for children."

"Erin Friday, parental rights advocate and lifelong Democrat, said she felt that her heart had "absolutely burst" and she "broke down in tears" of joy upon hearing the court's decision."

"The ruling has major legal implications for the 26 other states with similar bans on youth transgender procedures, Hans Spakovsky, Senior Legal Fellow at The Heritage Foundation, told CBN News."

"This ruling is good for people, for children who identify as trans too."

"Justice Thomas called out courts in a concurring opinion Wednesday for assuming “self-described experts” are always correct."

"The ruling was described as a "major blow," a "devastating loss," and a "stunning setback.""

"The decision has been met with triumphant approval from conservatives."

"This decision means that gender-related laws like SB1 are in the broad category of matters, such as regulating the practice of medicine generally, that the people and their elected representatives must handle."

"The court’s task is not, he adds, “to judge the wisdom, fairness, or logic” of the law."

"Despite the fact that the majority of Americans, regardless of political party, believe children should not be subject to such irreversible procedures, mainstream media reporters still referred to the High Court’s ruling as a “major setback” or a “devastating loss.”"

"The ruled Wednesday that a Tennessee law banning specific transgender medical treatments for adolescents in the state is not discriminatory, ruling 6-3 to uphold the law."

"Conservatives on social media rejoiced on social media Wednesday after the Supreme Court upheld a Tennessee law banning gender-transition treatments for adolescents."

"The Supreme Court upheld a Tennessee law prohibiting “sex transition treatments” for minors, more precisely described as “elective mutilations for children.”"

"Wu accused Strangio of expanding “what transsexual is to absolutely absurd degrees,” making it hard for them to defend any reasonable set of transgender rights in the courts for an all-or-nothing approach."

"The Supreme Court on Monday upheld a Tennessee law banning sex changes for minors."

"The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld Tennessee’s ban on gender-affirming surgery for transgender youth in a ruling that’s likely to reverberate across the country."

"The landmark ruling deals a bruising blow to the transgender rights movement, which in recent years has placed advocating for and protecting children’s access to gender-transition medications at the forefront of its increasingly demoralized civil-rights mission."

"This Supreme Court seems to have forgotten that one of their jobs is to protect individual rights and protect individuals from being discriminated against."

"The Court’s willingness to do so here does irrevocable damage to the Equal Protection Clause and invites legislatures to engage in discrimination by hiding blatant sex classifications in plain sight."

"I will suffer for the rest of my life for believing, in my confusion, the people who perpetuated these cruel lies."

"The ruling, backed by all six conservative justices and opposed by the three liberal justices, allows Tennessee to enforce its 2023 law."

"The court typically aims to finish its work by the end of June."

"This 6-3 opinion remains a cause for celebration."

"Justice Sonia Sotomayor shared her “sadness” Wednesday that children would no longer be able to access experimental and irreversible transgender procedures."

"This decision bodes well for the similar laws in at least 26 other states protecting children from these barbaric practices."

"The court affirmed that there’s a rational basis for the Tennessee law, given the adverse risks of transgender treatments and the possibility that children will regret them."

"The ruling will help protect 26 similar state laws and return common sense to America’s medical system."

"The Equal Protection Clause does not resolve these disagreements."

"The Supreme Court ruled Wednesday that states have the constitutional right to pass laws protecting children from irreversible transgender medical interventions."

"The court's ruling comes at a time when transgender rights are a hotly contested topic."

"This historic decision gives newfound hope and strength to every state bold enough to push back on these policies that prioritize money over children’s safety."

"Tennessee’s law blocks all transgender medical treatments on children, including puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries."

Articles (77)
Center (20)
FAQ
Tennessee's ban prohibits hormone replacement therapy and puberty blockers for transgender youth, as well as gender-affirming surgeries, which are rare for minors.
The Supreme Court ruled that Tennessee's ban does not violate the 14th Amendment’s equal protection clause. Chief Justice Roberts emphasized that while the issue raises sincere concerns, the court's role is limited to assessing constitutional compliance, leaving policy decisions to elected representatives.
The majority expressed concerns about the speed and evidence supporting medical treatments for children, upholding the ban as constitutional. The dissent, led by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, contended that the ruling could cause harm to transgender children, reflecting a deep divide in judicial perspectives.
The ruling has intensified debates on transgender rights and healthcare access, with some family groups supporting the decision while others express concerns about its negative effects on transgender youth. It also influences similar laws in 25 states that have banned or restricted gender-affirming care for minors.
The lawsuit, known as L.W. v. Skrmetti, was filed by the ACLU and Lambda Legal on behalf of families of transgender youth, including Samantha and Brian Williams of Nashville and their teenage daughter, as well as Dr. Susan Lacy, a Memphis-based gynecologist providing gender-affirming care.
History
- 3M4 articles
- 3M5 articles
- 3M15 articles
- 3M31 articles
- 3M48 articles
- 3M24 articles