Supreme Court Upholds States' Right to Block Medicaid Funding for Planned Parenthood
The Supreme Court's ruling allows states to block Medicaid funding to Planned Parenthood, raising concerns about healthcare access for low-income patients and potential clinic closures.
SCOTUS upholds state cut of Medicaid for Planned Parenthood
World News Group
BREAKING: Supreme Court rules Medicaid can DEFUND Planned Parenthood
The Post Millennial
Overview
- The U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6-3 allowing states to block Medicaid payments to Planned Parenthood, impacting healthcare access for low-income patients.
- South Carolina's Republican Governor Henry McMaster previously signed an executive order in 2018 to cut Medicaid funding to abortion providers, leading to ongoing legal disputes.
- Public health advocates warn that the ruling could force up to 200 of Planned Parenthood's 600 facilities to close, severely limiting access to vital healthcare services.
- Abortion opponents celebrate the ruling as a significant victory, while supporters of Planned Parenthood argue it hinders access to essential healthcare beyond abortion.
- The ruling's implications may vary by state, with the U.S. House also passing a budget measure to block federal payments to nonprofit groups providing abortion services.
Content generated by AI—learn more or report issue.
Get both sides in 5 minutes with our daily newsletter.
Analysis
Center-leaning sources frame the Supreme Court's ruling on Medicaid funding for Planned Parenthood as a significant legal and political development. They highlight contrasting perspectives: abortion opponents view it as a victory, while supporters see it as a detrimental blow to healthcare access, reflecting underlying biases on reproductive rights.
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that Medicaid patients do not have the right to sue for coverage of specific providers or to choose their doctor.
South Carolina has implemented a six-week abortion ban, making abortions rare in the state and restricting Medicaid funding for abortion care.
Medicaid funds are currently prohibited by the federal government and many states from being used to cover abortion services.
Abortion opponents view the ruling as a significant victory based on principle.
Supporters of Planned Parenthood view the ruling as a barrier to comprehensive healthcare services beyond abortion.
The U.S. House passed a budget measure that would prohibit federal payments for 10 years to nonprofit groups providing abortion, particularly those receiving over $1 million in federal funding in 2024.
Planned Parenthood warns that if the measure is passed, it could result in the closure of up to 200 of their 600 facilities nationwide.
Approximately 40% of Planned Parenthood's budget, totaling over $500 billion annually, is derived from Medicaid and other government sources, with one third of their revenue coming from state and federal government funding.
Justice Neil Gorsuch authored a 6-3 opinion in the ruling.
The ruling eliminates Planned Parenthood's main legal avenue to maintain Medicaid funding by blocking patient lawsuits.
Republicans have targeted Planned Parenthood for defunding due to its association with abortions, despite federal funding for abortion already being banned.
Planned Parenthood warns that a ruling may lead to the closure of approximately 200 clinics, primarily in states where abortion is legal.
Public health care funds are typically not allocated for abortion services.
Medicaid patients rely on Planned Parenthood for services like contraception, cancer screenings, and pregnancy testing.
Articles (29)
Center (9)
"…The ruling is a win for the pro-life community, women's health and taxpayers."
USA TODAY·18d·"…The ruling comes at a moment when Congress is considering blocking Planned Parenthood from receiving any federal Medicaid funding, a move that the group says would force hundreds of clinic closings — most of them in states where abortion remains legal."
ABC News·18d·"…The ruling comes at a moment when Congress is considering blocking Planned Parenthood from receiving any federal Medicaid funding, a move that the group says would force hundreds of clinic closings — most of them in states where abortion remains legal."
Associated Press·18d·"…The ruling is likely to result in tangible harm to real people, stripping Medicaid recipients of the ability to decide who treats them at their most vulnerable."
Chicago Sun-Times·18d·"…The ruling is likely to pave the way for more states to exclude Planned Parenthood from their Medicaid programs, a move that anti-abortion rights have been pushing for several years."
CBS News·18d·"…The Supreme Court's decision allows states to ban the organization from getting Medicaid reimbursements for cancer screenings and other care not related to abortion."
NPR·18d·"…The majority's decision will likely result in tangible harm to real people."
USA TODAY·18d·"…The ruling is a boost to the state's effort to prevent Planned Parenthood from receiving funding through Medicaid, as it prevents individual patients from enforcing their right to choose their preferred health care provider."
NBC News·18d·"…The ruling is likely to result in tangible harm to real people, stripping Medicaid recipients of the ability to decide who treats them at their most vulnerable."
Associated Press·18d·FAQ
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that states can block Medicaid payments to Planned Parenthood, allowing states to exclude the organization from their Medicaid programs.
The ruling could force the closure of up to 200 Planned Parenthood facilities out of 600, severely limiting access to vital healthcare services for low-income patients who rely on Medicaid.
Abortion opponents celebrate the ruling as a significant victory in their efforts to defund Planned Parenthood due to its abortion services, while supporters argue the decision hinders access to essential healthcare services beyond abortion, such as reproductive and sexual health care.
South Carolina's Republican Governor Henry McMaster signed an executive order in 2018 to cut Medicaid funding to abortion providers, including Planned Parenthood, which led to ongoing legal disputes culminating in this Supreme Court case.
Yes, the U.S. House has passed a budget measure to block federal payments to nonprofit groups providing abortion services, which could further impact funding for Planned Parenthood nationwide.
History
- 18d
3 articles - 18d
21 articles