ABC News logo
FOX News logo
NPR logo
68 articles
·4d

Supreme Court Limits Nationwide Injunctions, Leaves Birthright Citizenship Executive Order Unresolved

The Supreme Court's recent ruling restricts nationwide injunctions, impacting Trump's birthright citizenship executive order, but does not address its constitutionality.

Overview

A summary of the key points of this story verified across multiple sources.

  • The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to limit judges' ability to issue nationwide injunctions, affecting federal actions.
  • Justice Amy Coney Barrett authored the majority opinion, highlighting the need to prevent judicial overreach by lower courts.
  • The Court did not rule on the constitutionality of Trump's birthright citizenship executive order, leaving it unresolved for now.
  • Challengers are exploring new legal options, with Maryland lawyers filing an amended complaint for class-wide relief against the executive order.
  • Trump aims to use the ruling to further his birthright citizenship proposal and other policies amidst ongoing legal challenges.

Content generated by AI—learn more or report issue.

Pano Newsletter

Get both sides in 5 minutes with our daily newsletter.

Analysis

Compare how each side frames the story — including which facts they emphasize or leave out.

Center-leaning sources frame the birthright citizenship debate as a significant legal and political struggle, emphasizing the tension between immigrant rights advocates and the Trump administration. They express concern over the implications of the Supreme Court's rulings, suggesting a bias towards protecting established rights while critiquing executive overreach.

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of President Trump's executive order to partially end birthright citizenship, expanding his power.

BBC News logo
CBS News logo
ABC News logo
4 articles
100%

Federal district courts will need to reconsider the use of nationwide injunctions as the Supreme Court determines the extent of judges' authority to issue them.

BBC News logo
ABC News logo
Chicago Tribune logo
3 articles
100%

Rights groups and 22 states sued to block President Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship.

NPR logo
NPR logo
2 articles
100%

Challengers pursued the same outcome through alternative legal arguments.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Immigrant advocates are determined to protect birthright citizenship from the Republican president's attempts to overturn long-standing precedent, which has become linked to the administration's broader fight against nationwide injunctions.

Associated Press logo
CBS News logo
2 articles
100%

The Supreme Court instructed lower courts to review challenges to birthright citizenship policy and other related policies.

Associated Press logo
USA TODAY logo
2 articles
100%

The Supreme Court ruled to limit judges' ability to block President Trump's plan to end birthright citizenship.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

The ACLU filed a lawsuit in New Hampshire on behalf of immigrants challenging Trump's order potentially affecting their children's U.S. citizenship.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Lawyers in Maryland filed an amended complaint seeking class-wide relief for individuals impacted by Trump's plan.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Samuel Bray believes that states and individual plaintiffs can obtain broad injunctions against the birthright citizenship executive order.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Trump plans to use the Supreme Court ruling to advance his birthright citizenship proposal and other policies.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in favor of limiting universal injunctions issued by federal courts at the request of the Trump administration.

NPR logo
NPR logo
2 articles
100%

The U.S. Supreme Court will reargue Louisiana's congressional redistricting plan in its next term after a three-year battle over congressional districts in the state.

Chicago Tribune logo
NPR logo
2 articles
100%

Trump's administration believes not all individuals born in the U.S. should receive automatic citizenship, based on Trump's longstanding belief that it does not exist.

USA TODAY logo
NPR logo
2 articles
100%

The court granted the Trump administration's request to narrow the injunctions blocking the president's executive order in Trump v. CASA.

CBS News logo
Reason logo
2 articles
100%

The Justice Department argued against district judges having the authority to nationwide block presidential actions during legal challenges, with some justices expressing concern over the power of a single judge to do so.

USA TODAY logo
USA TODAY logo
2 articles
100%

The ruling does not evaluate the legality of the plan, but only considers whether judges can halt it nationwide.

NBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

The Supreme Court will meet on Friday to make final rulings on six cases, including the birthright citizenship dispute.

Chicago Tribune logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Barrett's ruling did not address the constitutionality or legality of Trump's executive order.

CBS News logo
Reason logo
MSNBC logo
3 articles
67%

Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship has a 30-day grace period before implementation.

ABC News logo
NPR logo
The Guardian logo
3 articles
67%

The Trump administration has stated that children of noncitizens do not have a right to citizenship.

Associated Press logo
Chicago Sun-Times logo
Newsmax logo
3 articles
67%

Birthright citizenship grants automatic American citizenship to anyone born in the United States, regardless of their parents' immigration status.

Associated Press logo
Associated Press logo
Chicago Sun-Times logo
7 articles
43%

Articles (68)

Compare how different news outlets are covering this story.

Center (27)

"…The decision could lead to a radical reshaping of a legal right to citizenship that's been long guaranteed by the 14th Amendment -- at least in the short term."

What's next for birthright citizenship after Supreme Court limits nationwide injunctions
ABC NewsABC News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court’s ruling leaves open the possibility that groups challenging the policy could still get nationwide relief through class-action lawsuits and seek certification as a nationwide class."

What's next for birthright citizenship after the Supreme Court's ruling
Associated PressAssociated Press·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court's ruling limiting the ability of judges to block President Donald Trump’s plan to end birthright citizenship has sparked new legal claims seeking similar results through different means."

What comes next after the Supreme Court's birthright citizenship ruling: From the Politics Desk
NBC NewsNBC News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The possibility that Trump could end the right granted by the 14th Amendment has raised alarm among groups that had hoped the Supreme Court would outright block his initiative."

Migrant groups left shocked, scared over Supreme Court ruling on birthright citizenship
USA TODAYUSA TODAY·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court term has given the Trump administration a series of major wins in the final blockbuster week of its term."

The Supreme Court gives Trump a wave of victories in a blockbuster final week
NPRNPR·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Trump administration scored a notable legal victory today when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6–3 that federal district judges "likely exceed" their authority when they issue nationwide injunctions that entirely block federal laws or presidential orders from going into effect while legal challenges play out in court."

Supreme Court rules 6–3 for Trump, limits 'nationwide injunctions' in birthright citizenship case
ReasonReason·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court on Friday handed a significant victory to Donald Trump - and future American presidents - when curbing lower courts' power to block executive orders."

Supreme Court decision on birthright citizenship broadens Trump's power
BBC NewsBBC News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…SCOTUS has empowered the president to impose whatever he likes—irrespective of its constitutionality—and then prevented judicial overview except at the localized level."

The Supreme Court Just Made America a Dangerous Place
The BulwarkThe Bulwark·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…President Trump praised the Supreme Court for its decision Friday limiting the ability of federal judges to impose nationwide injunctions, calling it a "monumental victory for the Constitution.""

Watch Live: Trump praises Supreme Court decision limiting use of nationwide injunctions
CBS NewsCBS News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…President Donald Trump took a victory lap on Friday after the Supreme Court limited nationwide injunctions issued by lower court judges against his executive order to effectively end birthright citizenship."

Trump celebrates Supreme Court decision limiting nationwide injunctions on birthright citizenship order
ABC NewsABC News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…This decision is a smart balance between allowing a president leeway to enact his agenda while preserving the judiciary's important role to check executive power."

Trump gets a win on injunctions, but will birthright citizenship order hold? | Opinion
USA TODAYUSA TODAY·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court on Friday limited the use of nationwide injunctions, reining in federal judges' ability to issue sweeping orders that have in recent years stymied implementation of policies from Republican and Democratic presidential administrations alike."

Supreme Court, in birthright citizenship case, limits judges' use of nationwide injunctions
CBS NewsCBS News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Court has put the kibosh on the growing practice of issuing universal injunctions."

ReasonReason·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court's decision asked the lower courts to reconsider their broad rulings in light of the Supreme Court's opinion and otherwise 'with principles of equity.'"

Supreme Court limits nationwide injunctions in birthright citizenship order
NPRNPR·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court on Friday handed a major win to the Trump administration by allowing it to take steps to implement its proposal to end automatic birthright citizenship."

Supreme Court curbs injunctions that blocked Trump's birthright citizenship plan
NBC NewsNBC News·4d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court is meeting Friday to decide the final six cases of its term, including President Donald Trump’s bid to enforce his executive order denying birthright citizenship to U.S.-born children of parents who are in the country illegally."

Supreme Court meets Friday to decide 6 remaining cases, including birthright citizenship
Chicago TribuneChicago Tribune·5d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The case before the Supreme Court doesn’t focus on the lawfulness of the proposal itself, but rather on whether federal judges have the power to block it nationwide while litigation continues."

Supreme Court set to make rulings and CDC vaccine committee meeting: Morning Rundown
NBC NewsNBC News·5d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…The Supreme Court is expected to decide one of the most consequential cases in modern US history on Friday - whether a single federal judge can block an order from the US president from taking effect nationwide."

What to know about the Supreme Court birthright citizenship case
BBC NewsBBC News·5d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

FAQ

Dig deeper on this story with frequently asked questions.

Nationwide injunctions are court orders that block the enforcement of federal policies across the entire country. The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to limit their use because they often exceed the authority Congress has given to federal courts, potentially leading to judicial overreach by lower courts.

The ruling allows the Trump administration to partially enforce the birthright citizenship executive order while legal proceedings continue, but only to the extent that previous injunctions were broader than necessary. The Court did not decide on the constitutionality of the order itself, leaving that unresolved.

Justice Barrett emphasized that federal courts do not have general oversight of the executive branch but resolve specific cases consistent with congressional authority. She argued that when courts find executive actions unlawful, they should not exceed their power by issuing universal injunctions.

Challengers are exploring new legal avenues, including filing amended complaints for class-wide relief against the birthright citizenship executive order, aiming to address the issue through class action procedures which the Court indicated as a proper route for broad relief.

No, the ruling does not completely eliminate nationwide injunctions. The Supreme Court indicated that judges can grant relief similar to nationwide injunctions in certain cases, such as when a state sues the federal government and proper procedural requirements are met.

History

See how this story has evolved over time.

  • 4d
    Associated Press logo
    The New Yorker logo
    NBC News logo
    9 articles
  • 4d
    USA TODAY logo
    Daily Signal logo
    Slate logo
    14 articles
  • 4d
    CBS News logo
    ABC News logo
    USA TODAY logo
    38 articles
  • 4d
    Chicago Tribune logo
    USA TODAY logo
    NBC News logo
    4 articles