Emil Bove Confirmed as U.S. Appeals Court Judge Amid Controversy
Emil Bove's confirmation as a judge for the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals was marked by a narrow Senate vote and significant opposition due to whistleblower allegations.
Senate confirms Emil Bove as judge despite whistleblowers' claims
Washington Examiner
Overview
- Emil Bove, former attorney for President Trump, confirmed as a judge for the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
- The Senate confirmed Bove with a narrow 50-49 vote, primarily along party lines.
- Republican Senators Collins and Murkowski voted against Bove's confirmation amid fierce opposition.
- Whistleblower allegations claimed Bove suggested ignoring court orders and misled about federal corruption charges.
- Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley dismissed the allegations, while Bove denied them during his confirmation hearing.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources frame this story by emphasizing the contentious nature of Emil Bove's judicial confirmation. They highlight his past as a "Trump loyalist" and his role in a "tumultuous period" at the Justice Department. The coverage details "fierce opposition" from Democrats and former DOJ employees, focusing on numerous allegations of undermining integrity and political interference, even while including his denials.
"Bove overcame fierce opposition from Democrats, who walked out in protest when the Senate Judiciary Committee advanced his nomination, and more than 900 former Justice Department employees, who accused Bove of undermining the integrity of the department."
USA TODAY"The Senate confirmed former Trump lawyer Emil Bove 50-49 for a lifetime appointment as a federal appeals court judge Tuesday as Republicans dismissed whistleblower complaints about his conduct at the Justice Department."
NPR"Bove is considered Trump's most contentious judicial pick to date, having defended him in three of the four criminal trials he faced after finishing his first term in office in 2020."
BBC News"The Senate confirmed former Trump lawyer Emil Bove 50-49 for a lifetime appointment as a federal appeals court judge Tuesday as Republicans dismissed whistleblower complaints about his conduct at the Justice Department."
ABC News"Bove emerged as Mr. Trump's most controversial judicial pick so far, and former judges, prosecutors and other Justice Department employees had urged senators to reject his nomination."
CBS News"The Republican-led Senate voted Tuesday to confirm Emil Bove as a judge on the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, granting a lifetime appointment to President Donald Trump's former personal lawyer."
NBC NewsArticles (15)
Center (6)
FAQ
Whistleblowers alleged that Emil Bove suggested ignoring court orders, misled Congress about federal corruption charges, and was involved in the Trump administration's violation of a court order regarding the transfer of Venezuelan nationals to El Salvador. They also claimed he played a central role in conduct leading to probable cause for criminal contempt and scuttled DOJ bribery prosecution of New York City Mayor Eric Adams as part of a political quid pro quo.
Emil Bove was confirmed to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals by a narrow Senate vote of 50-49, primarily along party lines, with Republican Senators Collins and Murkowski voting against his confirmation.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley dismissed the allegations against Bove, stating that his staff made exhaustive efforts to vet the nomination and were given limited access to evidence from whistleblowers. Bove denied misleading the committee and claimed he answered questions truthfully.
Yes, two Senate Judiciary Democrats, Adam Schiff and Cory Booker, requested the Justice Department's Inspector General to investigate allegations against Emil Bove. This came after a third whistleblower came forward with additional testimony questioning Bove's fitness for the bench.
History
- 1M
9 articles