Trump Executive Order Targets Flag Burning with Jail Terms, Defying Supreme Court Ruling
President Trump issued an executive order directing the Justice Department to pursue one-year jail terms for flag burning, directly challenging a 1989 Supreme Court decision protecting it as free speech.
Man arrested outside of White House after burning flag to protest Trump EO
The Post Millennial
Burn, baby, burn
Reason
Trump signs order against flag burning despite 1st Amendment protections
New York Daily News
Overview
- President Donald Trump issued an executive order directing the Justice Department to pursue criminal penalties, including one-year jail terms, for individuals involved in burning or desecrating the American flag.
- This order directly challenges a 1989 Supreme Court decision that protected flag burning as a form of political expression under the First Amendment, aiming to bypass the ruling.
- The administration plans to explore charges like disturbing the peace or inciting violence to prosecute flag burning, bypassing current federal law that doesn't explicitly criminalize it.
- The White House justifies the executive order by emphasizing the American flag's status as a sacred national symbol and noting public support for making its destruction illegal.
- The order also suggests potential deportation or visa revocation for foreign nationals involved in flag burning, potentially leading to a renewed Supreme Court debate on the issue.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources cover the story neutrally by consistently juxtaposing President Trump's executive order and statements against the established Supreme Court precedent that flag burning is protected speech. They focus on legal context and factual reporting, ensuring readers understand the constitutional implications without employing loaded language or selective emphasis.
"This executive order is symbolism and theater."
NPR"Trump’s order states that the sight of someone disrespecting an American flag — and particularly burning one — is “uniquely offensive and provocative.”"
Associated Press"The arrest happened around 6:15 p.m. Aug. 25, after Trump's executive order directing his administration to prosecute such incidents when connected to other crimes "to the fullest extent possible.""
USA TODAY"It's rather king-like and gross to try to force this type of patriotism."
Reason"The executive order is all about the vibes, and I'm sure many politicians and interest groups on both ends of the political spectrum will use this to energize the base and raise some more small-dollar donations."
Reason"Trump has often employed the symbolism of the American flag throughout his political career and as a prominent visual in the pro-Trump MAGA movement."
USA TODAY"The order appears to expressly contemplate that, both by mentioning "fighting words" and by mentioning "disorderly conduct laws.""
Reason"The directive acknowledges a 36-year-old Supreme Court decision that found flag burning is protected speech but adds that "American flag desecration conducted in a manner that is likely to incite imminent lawless action or that is an action amounting to 'fighting words'" may not be entitled to the same protection under the First Amendment."
CBS News"Trump's executive order clearly seeks to erode this clear distinction between expressive acts that could inspire lawlessness and expressive acts that directly call for lawlessness."
Reason"The order states that desecrating the American flag is “uniquely offensive and provocative,” and it may incite violence and riot."
ABC News"The order states that desecrating the American flag is “uniquely offensive and provocative.”"
Associated Press"Trump was flanked by top officials for the signing, including Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, Vice President JD Vance and Attorney General Pam Bondi."
ABC News"Trump's order comes amid a year of celebration leading to the country’s 250th birthday on July 4, 2026."
USA TODAYArticles (42)
Center (13)
FAQ
President Trump's executive order directs the Justice Department to pursue criminal penalties, including one-year jail terms, for flag burning, challenging the 1989 Supreme Court decision that protects flag burning as free speech, by focusing on charges like inciting violence or disturbing the peace instead.
The executive order instructs prosecutors to use existing laws such as those against inciting violence or disturbing the peace to criminally charge flag burning, thereby attempting to bypass the Supreme Court's 1989 ruling that protects flag burning as political expression under the First Amendment.
The order suggests potential deportation, visa revocation, or termination of immigration benefits for foreign nationals involved in flag burning, applying immigration law remedies to such acts.
The White House justifies the order by emphasizing the American flag as a sacred national symbol representing freedom and unity, stating that desecration is uniquely offensive and provocative, often used to intimidate and incite violence, and noting public support for making flag burning illegal.
President Trump has described individuals who burn the American flag as acting with contempt and hostility toward the nation, calling them "animals" and stating they do not love America, expressing determination to ensure such acts lead to jail time.
History
- 1d
4 articles
- 2d
5 articles
- 2d4 articles
- 2d
9 articles
- 2d
9 articles