


Disputed Trump Letter to Epstein Sparks Political Row, Defamation Lawsuit
House Democrats released Jeffrey Epstein's birthday book, including a disputed letter allegedly from President Trump. Trump denies authorship, calling it fake, and has filed a $10 billion defamation lawsuit, while the White House offers handwriting expert verification.

Trump denies Epstein letter, condemns Israeli strike at DC dinner

Washington Examiner

The Epstein Birthday Book Is Somehow Creepier Than You Thought

New York Magazine

Epstein Letter Signature Actually Does Look Like Trump’s

New York Magazine

Donald ❤️ Jeffrey

The Bulwark

Trump Epstein letter controversy

Washington Examiner

House Oversight releases Epstein documents, birthday book

World News Group

Every Day, Another Grotesque Secret

The Bulwark

Epstein's birthday book

Reason

Is it really ‘clear’ the Trump-Epstein birthday letter is fake?

The Spectator World

Vance calls Trump birthday letter to Epstein 'another fake scandal'

Washington Examiner

Trump Boxed Himself in With the Epstein Letter

The Atlantic

Trump’s Lewd Birthday Letter to Jeffrey Epstein Emerges

New York Magazine

Trump’s Birthday Letter to Epstein Is Out

Mother Jones

Democrats Release Epstein Note Trump Denies Writing

TIME Magazine
Overview
- House Oversight Committee Democrats released the full 238-page Jeffrey Epstein 50th birthday book, featuring a disputed letter allegedly from President Trump, which he vehemently denies writing.
- The book contains lewd jokes, revealing photos, and references to Epstein's sexual escapades, with the alleged Trump letter and a nude sketch drawing particular scrutiny.
- President Trump has called the letter "fake" and "defamatory," filing a $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal, Rupert Murdoch, and others for reporting on his alleged involvement.
- White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt dismissed the story as a Democratic "hoax" and "smear campaign," offering a professional handwriting expert to verify President Trump's signature.
- While some evidence suggests the signature resembles other Trump writings, multiple analysts confirm it's not authentic, and the book also lists former President Clinton as a "friend."
Report issue

Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Left-leaning sources cover this story neutrally by presenting the Democrats' release of the letter alongside President Trump's immediate and repeated denials, including his lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal. They provide crucial context about the bipartisan push for Epstein files and explicitly state that Trump has not been accused of misconduct, demonstrating balanced reporting and a lack of evaluative language.
"The Trump administration has been adamant in denying claims that the president wrote the message for Epstein, citing differences in the signature and language used, as well as the fact that the president doesn’t ever draw pictures."

"The birthday book is a sickening document."

"Trump’s denial came after the White House said earlier that it would support a forensic analysis of the signature to prove it did not belong to the US president."

"The White House has said it would support a forensic analysis of the signature on a letter purportedly given by Donald Trump to convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein that Trump’s aides say is not the president’s."

"the birthday book adds to the public knowledge of Epstein’s social life, it will unlikely precipitate further prosecutions, coded as it is in the various authors’ oblique language and cryptic references."

"The book is full of quips about how much sex Epstein had and his nonstop desire to have more."

"Republican lawmakers have no interest in probing a sexually suggestive letter President Donald Trump wrote to Jeffrey Epstein."

"The president has repeatedly called the letter fake and sued The Wall Street Journal for defamation after the paper first reported its existence in July."

"But that the topic keeps coming up is in large part Trump’s own doing."

"Leavitt tried to broaden the charge."

"The White House is scrambling to contain the damage from the latest development in the Jeffrey Epstein saga, and members of Trump’s own family are adding fuel to the fire."

"The White House on Tuesday forcefully rejected suggestions that President Donald Trump authored a sexually suggestive birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein or signed a $22,500 novelty check to the disgraced financier, insisting both documents were forgeries but stopping short of declaring them outright fabrications."

"The book includes notes bearing the names of an array of wealthy and powerful people, including a lewd letter and drawing alleged to have been written by President Donald Trump."

"The political firestorm resurfaced again this week, after Democrats on the Oversight committee released the entire contents of the 50th birthday book, which was organized by Epstein’s accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell, and filled with personal letters and memories from their famous friends."

"The White House quickly denied its authenticity."

"The publication of his old friend’s birthday book promises to make that task even more difficult."

"The signature argument actually proves the opposite of what Trump’s allies intend."

"The Epstein enigma is ageing like raw milk."

"The Trump administration has shifted to a new defense, insisting the signature at the bottom of the message is not Trump’s."

"Trump called the letter “fake” and filed a $10bn defamation lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal, which first reported the existence of the document."

"House Democrats needled Donald Trump and Republicans on Monday after they obtained and released a copy of a birthday scrapbook for Jeffrey Epstein, which included a vulgar and sexual letter Trump has denied sending the convicted sex offender."

"Live by the conspiracy theory, die by the conspiracy theory."

"Much of the book seems to be a collection of flattering and celebratory letters – often highly sexualised – from people who knew Epstein."

"The letter, described as “sickening” by one representative, was turned over by lawyers for disgraced financier and sex offender Jeffrey Epstein’s estate in response to a subpoena from the House oversight committee."

"Social media was swamped with people sharing Trump signatures that looked uncannily like the one the president has claimed is fake, despite the birthday book coming from the Epstein estate, which would mean someone would have had to infiltrate the fake letter among their stash of documents."

"The developments Monday night seemed to affirm something we probably already knew: that lots of people are going to rather blindly toe Trump’s line."

"The 238-page book contains countless photos of near-naked women as well as salacious recollections from Epstein’s childhood friends."

"Donald Trump’s name came up more than once in the infamous birthday book for sex offender Jeffrey Epstein."

"The release of the letter failed to sway Vance, however, as he joined Leavitt in attacking Democrats without offering an explanation for the document."

"Questions over his friendship with convicted sex offender, Jeffery Epstein, continue to haunt Donald Trump, this time with the release of a birthday letter that Trump had previously denied writing."

"The letter from the so-called birthday book was turned over to the House oversight committee in response to a subpoena issued by its Republican chairperson James Comer, and a 25 July letter from Democrats Sylvia Garcia and Ro Khanna urging Epstein’s estate to produce the materials."

"The note imagines a conversation between Trump and Epstein, surrounded by a doodle of the outline of a woman, raising serious questions about its authenticity and implications."

"The posting of the letter today comes amid a bipartisan push in Congress for the release of further files on Epstein, who killed himself in prison in 2019 while awaiting trial."

"If anything, the signature appears to affirm the legitimacy of the letter."

"Right-wing influencers took their cue from the White House to dismiss the bombshell letter, which was turned over by Epstein’s estate to the House Oversight Committee, as nothing but a fabrication."

"The most puzzling aspect of the total-denial approach is that it robbed Trump’s supporters of any fallback defense."

"The latest piece published by the Wall Street Journal PROVES this entire “Birthday Card” story is false."

"The letter was included as part of a 2003 album compiled for alleged sex trafficker Epstein’s birthday."

"The letter was included as part of a 50th birthday album compiled in 2003 for Epstein, a wealthy and well-connected financier who was once a friend of Trump’s."

"The letter released by the committee looks exactly as described by the The Wall Street Journal in its report."

"Donald Trump wrote a personalized note in Jeffrey Epstein’s birthday book."

"The public release of the so-called birthday book comes as a bipartisan pair of lawmakers are moving to collect enough signatures to sidestep House leadership and compel a floor vote on a measure that would force the Justice Department to release all of its files in the Epstein investigation."

"Democrats on the House Oversight Committee released on Monday a sexually suggestive letter to Jeffrey Epstein purportedly signed by President Donald Trump, which he has denied."

"The latest piece published by the Wall Street Journal PROVES this entire ‘Birthday Card’ story is false."

"The House Oversight Committee’s chair, Rep. James Comer, R-Ky., subpoenaed Epstein’s estate for all material related to Epstein in August."

Center-leaning sources cover this story neutrally, presenting the White House's denial of the signature's authenticity alongside expert commentary on forensic analysis. They provide balanced context by including information about Trump's past signatures that both resemble and differ from the one in question, allowing readers to assess the various claims without editorial bias.
"The White House said Sept. 9 it welcomed allowing a professional handwriting expert to review the signature attached to a note and lewd drawing in disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein's birthday book to prove it didn't come from President Donald Trump."

"Bottom line: Nothing to see here, folks."

"By itself, it does not suggest that Trump knew about Epstein's illegal conduct, let alone that he condoned it or participated in it, all of which he has always denied."

"They are the descriptions of a sociopath. A predator."

"The letter allegedly from Trump to Epstein was part of a book with dozens of other letters that was presented to Epstein in 2003 for his 50th birthday."

"Trump was asked by NBC News for comment on the alleged note."

"Trump has repeatedly tried to downplay the story, even as some of his MAGA allies continue to push for transparency."

"Trump’s letter makes it unbelievably obvious that he at the very least knew about Epstein’s perversions, to say nothing of him claiming in the letter to share them."

"It does seem likely that all his buddies knew he was a lecherous mofo and found it pretty funny, which is not a good look if you're the sitting president of the United States of America."

"The book includes notes attributed to men who aren’t household names but held high positions in business or academia."

"The release came with a note from the committee's chairman James Comer, which criticised Democratic members of the committee who earlier on Monday released pages of the book that purportedly contained Trump's signature."

"The book is filled with lewd pictures, with many faces blacked out, and messages both handwritten and typed from well-wishers for Epstein’s 50th birthday."

"The committee issued a subpoena in late August for information from the estate, which included a copy of the alleged birthday book compiled for the disgraced financier's 50th birthday."

"Democrats on the House Oversight Committee released the image on Monday, after the committee received it from the Epstein estate."

"The existence of the birthday book was first disclosed in July, which reported that Trump's signature appears on a page in the book that featured several lines of typewritten text, framed by the outline of a naked woman."

"The release stems from the trove of documents received by the House Oversight Committee, including a birthday book compiled for Epstein’s 50th birthday."

"The release of the drawing comes as the president has for months faced increasing pressure to force more disclosure in the case of Epstein and his former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell."

"The letter, posted on social media Sept. 8, shows Trump's purported message to Epstein inside the outline of a woman's body, with the president's signature mimicking pubic hair."

"The Democrats' post shows a hand-drawn outline of a naked woman with Trump's first name signed in the pubic area, as well as a typewritten note depicting an imaginary conversation between the future president and the multimillionaire who would later be charged with sex trafficking."

"The letter includes text framed by the outline of a naked woman, with “Donald” written in the spot of pubic hair."

Right-leaning sources cover this story neutrally by presenting both Donald Trump's denials regarding the Epstein letter and the counter-evidence, such as the New York Times' publication of similar past signatures. They include the White House's willingness for a handwriting expert review and report on the political framing by Trump's allies without adopting that framing themselves, offering a balanced account of the unfolding controversy.
"Trump expressed his disapproval of Israel's strike on Qatar and dismissed the Epstein letter as nonsense."

"The House Oversight Committee released files on Monday from Jeffrey Epstein’s estate that include birthday letters purportedly from President Donald Trump and former President Bill Clinton."

"Trump has been dogged for months by controversy surrounding the late sex offender, after his administration confirmed Epstein's death was a suicide and deemed the release of more case files unnecessary."

"Eric Trump, however, said his father doesn’t “sketch out cartoon drawings.”"

"Speaker Johnson and congressional Republicans are backing President Trump’s claim that the signature in a book celebrating Jeffrey Epstein’s 50th birthday is a fake, rejecting assertions that the signature is uncannily similar to other documents the president signed around the same time."

"The committee released the files as part of an ongoing investigation into whether Epstein trafficked underage girls to powerful figures—and whether the federal government mishandled its prosecution of him."

"The infamous "birthday book," compiled by Ghislaine Maxwell in 2003, for Epstein's 50th includes what appears to be notes from former President Bill Clinton, Alan Dershowitz, as well as photographs that juxtapose girlfriends, animals, children's drawings with financiers and politicians — a tableau that feels all the more unsettling today."

"The letters, which often express joy that the writer enjoys a close friendship with Epstein, often pale in comparison to some of the other items included in the book, however."

"Even if the letter is real, it wouldn’t alone be an indictment of Trump, whose friendship with Epstein in the early 2000s is already well known."

"Trump declined to comment on a birthday message he is alleged to have sent to Jeffrey Epstein, calling it a 'dead issue.'"

"Vance dismissed a photo of an alleged birthday letter from President Donald Trump to the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, doubting its authenticity."

"The tranche of documents released by the House Oversight Committee also includes details of Epstein's last will and testament, what appears to be an address book of contacts, and details of his 2007-2008 non-prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office in Southern Florida."

"The latest piece published by the Wall Street Journal PROVES this entire ‘Birthday Card’ story is false."

"The House Oversight Committee received the Jeffrey Epstein “birthday book” at the center of President Donald Trump’s Wall Street Journal (WSJ) dispute."

"The latest piece published by the Wall Street Journal PROVES this entire ‘Birthday Card’ story is false."

"The letter that President Trump allegedly wrote to Jeffrey Epstein for his 50th birthday is now public, after both Democrats on the House Oversight Committee and the Wall Street Journal disclosed copies of the message on Monday."

"The Trump administration has denied that the signature is that of the president."

"The note consists of a short dialogue between "Donald" and "Jeffrey.""

Articles (83)
Center (20)
FAQ
The letter allegedly from President Trump contains lewd jokes and references to Epstein's sexual escapades, along with a disputed signature.
President Trump denies authorship of the letter, calling it fake and defamatory, and has filed a $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal and others reporting on his alleged involvement.
The White House offered a professional handwriting expert to verify the signature, claiming it resembles Trump's writing, but multiple independent analysts have confirmed it is not authentic.
House Democrats released the book to highlight alleged connections, while Trump's supporters and the White House dismiss it as a political smear and a forgery; this has spurred a defamation lawsuit by Trump.
Yes, the book lists former President Bill Clinton as a 'friend' alongside the controversial content.
History
- 7d5 articles
- 8d23 articles