Federal Appeals Court Suspends Judge's Order for Border Patrol Commander Amid Chicago Protests and New Lawsuits
A federal appeals court temporarily suspended a judge's order for a Border Patrol commander's daily court appearances in Chicago, amidst new lawsuits and protest-related charges.
Overview
- Lawsuits alleging excessive force by federal agents were filed in Chicago, coinciding with nationwide efforts to restrict federal troop deployments during protests.
- Judge Sara Ellis initially ordered Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino to appear in court and wear body cameras during "Operation Midway Blitz" due to alleged chemical agent use.
- Judge Ellis later mandated daily in-person meetings with Commander Bovino, citing alleged violations of her temporary restraining order on tear gas and riot control.
- The DOJ requested a federal appeals court to pause daily meetings, arguing irreparable harm to Bovino's duties, a request the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily granted.
- Prosecutors charged a Democratic congressional candidate and others for obstructing an agent's car during protests at an immigration enforcement building, adding to the legal complexities.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources frame this story by emphasizing Judge Ellis's assertive efforts to curb alleged federal agent misconduct and protect local communities, particularly children. They highlight the judge's strong stance against the "Trump administration's" aggressive tactics, portraying the federal operation as problematic and the government's legal challenges as temporary procedural maneuvers.
"The ruling comes a day after Bovino showed up in Chicago’s federal court to answer questions about a series of aggressive immigration actions in the area since September."
NBC News"The appellate court could find the request reasonable and reinstate the requirement for Bovino to meet with Judge Ellis daily."
CBS News"The federal appeals court in Chicago put a temporary hold on the Tuesday order from U.S. District Judge Sara Ellis requiring the Border Patrol commander-at-large to appear in her courtroom every weeknight until Nov. 5."
Chicago Sun-Times"The judge expressed confidence Tuesday that the check-ins will prevent excessive use of force in Chicago’s neighborhoods."
Associated Press"The judge spoke at one point in somber tones about a fracas in the Old Irving Park neighborhood over the weekend where agents tackled angry residents and deployed tear gas on a quiet street as children were preparing to march in a Halloween parade to a nearby grammar school."
Chicago Tribune"U.S. District Court Judge Sara L. Ellis on Oct. 28 ordered Homeland Security officials to turn over all use of force reports and related body-worn camera footage that the agency has in connection with the Chicago-area crackdown; provide information on anyone arrested in connection with protesting immigration enforcement; and have the Border Patrol's top leader in the area deliver daily reports in person at the courthouse as well as begin using a body-worn camera."
USA TODAY"The judge wants him to meet her in person daily at 6 p.m. “to hear about how the day went.”"
ABC News"Ellis said it “should have been a really happy day.”"
Chicago Sun-Times"Bovino was captured in what are now well-publicized videos and photos tossing what appeared to be a tear gas canister into a crowd during an operation in the Chicago’s heavily Latino Little Village area last week."
NBC News"The hearing comes after a judge earlier this month ordered uniformed immigration agents to wear body cameras, the latest step in a lawsuit by news outlets and protesters who say federal agents used excessive force, including using tear gas, during protests against immigration operations."
Associated Press"The incident dates back to Oct. 23 amid an immigration enforcement raid on Little Village, a South Side neighborhood and the heart of Chicago’s Mexican community."
USA TODAYArticles (17)
Center (11)
FAQ
The primary goal of Operation Midway Blitz is to arrest illegal immigrants with criminal records, as part of a broader effort to crack down on sanctuary policies.
The operation has caused anxiety among certain Chicago residents, particularly Latinos. Protests have grown, and religious organizations have coordinated to provide support for immigrants.
Governor JB Pritzker's office is planning legal action, and lawsuits have been filed alleging excessive force by federal agents. A federal appeals court has temporarily suspended a judge's order related to a Border Patrol commander.
History
- 17h
3 articles - 20h
3 articles
- 2d4 articles
- 2d3 articles