DOJ Charges California Noncitizen Voters

Federal prosecutors accused 28 California green card holders of illegal voting.

Balanced

13 left10 center20 right

Updated Oct 19, 8:52pm ET

Both sides, every morning

The day’s biggest stories and how each side covered them. Free.

What happened

The Justice Department charged 28 California green-card holders with election-related offenses, including unlawful registration or voting and false statements on naturalization applications. The department also sued California, seeking an emergency order requiring officials to set aside ballots tied to people on its list until citizenship is verified. The charges came amid a dispute over more than 20,000 California voter records the department considers likely noncitizens, with mail voting already underway before the November 3 midterms. The department said it was protecting citizens’ votes; California officials said the list lacked support and usable methods. Authorities said 11 defendants had been arrested. The emergency request remained pending.

How each side covered it

From the left

Left-leaning outlets framed the charges as an escalation of a political fight over election control, not just a criminal case. The New York Times tied the move to Trump’s broader push over the midterms and stressed that proven noncitizen voting remains extremely rare. The Guardian focused on expert fears that flawed lists could wrongly target citizens.

From the right

Right-leaning outlets treated the charges as proof that federal election-integrity warnings deserved action, not dismissal. The New York Post cast the operation as a major crackdown and portrayed California resistance as minimizing a real voting problem. The Daily Mail emphasized that the arrests advanced Trump’s illegal-voting drive while noting the limited evidence of widespread impact.

Headlines