Fifth Circuit Voids Proxy-Passed Law
A federal appeals court said House proxy voting invalidated a 2022 Biden-era spending law.
Nov 21, 2026November 21, 2026
45%
Left · 4
33%
Center · 3
22%
Right · 2
Pano counted 9 articles from 9 outlets: 45% left-leaning, 33% center and 22% right-leaning. Pano rates the coverage Balanced.
What happened
- The Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 9-8 that a $1.7 trillion spending law passed unconstitutionally because lawmakers voting by proxy could not count toward the required majority present.
- The House passed the measure in December 2022 under pandemic rules allowing absent lawmakers to have other members cast votes for them.
- The ruling upheld an injunction sought by Texas blocking enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which was included in the spending law.
- That act requires employers to provide accommodations for pregnant workers, including bathroom and water breaks, relief from heavy lifting and time off for prenatal appointments.
- The decision is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court, and legal experts warned it could have broader effects beyond the pregnant-worker protections.
How the left told it
Left-leaning outlets largely emphasized the loss of pregnant-worker protections and the ruling’s wider consequences. The New York Times and Boston Globe detailed workplace accommodations at stake and potential national ripple effects; The Washington Post highlighted Texas’s injunction, while CNN led with the broader spending law’s unconstitutional passage.
How the right told it
Right-leaning outlets emphasized the constitutional limits on pandemic proxy voting. The Washington Examiner quoted the judges saying the quorum clause “does not allow proxies” while detailing lost pregnant-worker protections. The Washington Times took a sharper political tone, calling Pelosi’s system a “scheme” and describing misuse by Democrats and Republicans.
Washington Post
Reason
Washington Times
CNN


The New York Times

Boston Globe