BBC News logo
Boston Herald logo
NBC News logo
13 articles
·11d

Kilmar Abrego Garcia's Torture Allegations Resurface Amid Legal Battles in U.S.

Kilmar Abrego Garcia, extradited to the U.S. in June, alleges severe torture in El Salvador prison while facing human smuggling charges in Tennessee.

Overview

A summary of the key points of this story verified across multiple sources.

  • Kilmar Abrego Garcia was extradited to the U.S. in June to face human smuggling charges in Tennessee after being deported to El Salvador.
  • He alleges severe torture, including physical beatings and psychological abuse, during his nearly three-month imprisonment in an El Salvador mega-jail.
  • Garcia lost over 30 pounds in two weeks due to mistreatment, including forced kneeling and sleep deprivation, according to his lawyers.
  • Despite being ruled eligible for release by a federal judge, Garcia remains in custody amid fears of deportation and ongoing torture claims.
  • The Trump administration seeks to dismiss a lawsuit regarding his deportation, arguing it is moot since he has returned to the U.S. after the Supreme Court's ruling.

Content generated by AI—learn more or report issue.

Pano Newsletter

Get both sides in 5 minutes with our daily newsletter.

Analysis

Compare how each side frames the story — including which facts they emphasize or leave out.

Center-leaning sources frame the narrative around Kilmar Abrego García's alleged torture and mistreatment in a Salvadoran prison, emphasizing his claims of innocence and the denial of charges. They express skepticism towards government assertions linking him to gangs, highlighting systemic issues in the justice system and advocating for human rights protections.

The Trump administration has accused Mr Ábrego García of being a member of MS-13 based on alleged tattoos, a claim denied by his family and lawyers.

BBC News logo
CBS News logo
NBC News logo
3 articles
100%

He lost over 30 pounds due to mistreatment, sleep deprivation, and inadequate nutrition during his first two weeks in prison in El Salvador.

BBC News logo
Associated Press logo
USA TODAY logo
3 articles
100%

Kilmar Abrego Garcia endured severe physical and psychological torture in a high-security prison in El Salvador.

Associated Press logo
CBS News logo
USA TODAY logo
6 articles
67%

Mr Ábrego García and 20 other prisoners were allegedly forced to kneel all night long in a cell, with guards striking anyone who fell from exhaustion.

BBC News logo
Associated Press logo
NBC News logo
4 articles
75%

Prison officials repeatedly threatened to transfer Abrego to cells with gang members who would harm him.

Associated Press logo
USA TODAY logo
NBC News logo
4 articles
75%

He pleaded not guilty to the charges and was not charged with any crime or cited for any wrongdoing at the time.

BBC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Abrego was subjected to physical abuse, forced nudity, and extreme weight loss at CECOT prison in El Salvador, according to court documents.

CBS News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Screams from nearby cells went unanswered by prison guards throughout the night.

USA TODAY logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Abrego and four others were transferred to a different module in CECOT on April 9, and despite being transferred to a different prison in early April, Abrego Garcia was still denied contact with his attorneys or family members.

CBS News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

The individual was transferred to the Centro Industrial prison facility in Santa Ana, El Salvador, where he was often kept away from visitors.

ABC News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

The Supreme Court and a federal judge both ruled that his removal was illegal and ordered his return or release.

USA TODAY logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Abrego Garcia's lawyers are requesting his return to Maryland and a separate habeas corpus hearing to be held there.

CBS News logo
NBC News logo
2 articles
100%

Despite being ruled eligible for release by a federal judge in Tennessee, Mr. Ábrego García has remained in jail due to fears of immediate deportation.

BBC News logo
CBS News logo
Boston Herald logo
3 articles
67%

Abrego was deported to El Salvador on March 15 and placed into CECOT, a notorious megaprison with harsh conditions.

Associated Press logo
NBC News logo
Boston Herald logo
3 articles
67%

Detainees were confined to overcrowded cells with metal bunks lacking mattresses, windows, and with bright lights that remained on 24 hours a day.

BBC News logo
NBC News logo
The Guardian logo
4 articles
50%

Articles (13)

Compare how different news outlets are covering this story.

Center (6)

"…Lawyers for Kilmar Ábrego García, 29, alleged that assaults from guards left him with visible injuries within a day of his arrival at the CECOT prison."

Kilmar Ábrego García alleges torture and abuse in El Salvador mega-jail
BBC NewsBBC News·11d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…Abrego Garcia experienced "severe beatings" and "psychological torture" in a notorious high-security prison in El Salvador after he was deported by the Trump administration."

Kilmar Abrego Garcia was beaten, tortured in El Salvador prison, court filing says
USA TODAYUSA TODAY·12d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

"…Abrego Garcia was subjected to severe mistreatment including "beatings, severe deprivation, inadequate nutrition and psychological torture" upon his arrival in March at CECOT, the notorious mega-prison in El Salvador, according to a newly proposed amended complaint from his lawyers."

Abrego Garcia was subjected to 'severe mistreatment' at CECOT, his lawyers say
ABC NewsABC News·12d·
Center
This outlet is balanced or reflects centrist views.

FAQ

Dig deeper on this story with frequently asked questions.

Kilmar Abrego Garcia alleged severe mistreatment including beatings, being forcibly chained, psychological torture such as forced kneeling, sleep deprivation, denial of basic needs, inadequate nutrition, and repeated physical strikes by prison officers upon his arrival at CECOT prison in El Salvador.

He was deported to El Salvador despite a 2019 court order barring his deportation due to fears of persecution. The Trump administration claimed Garcia was a member of the MS-13 gang, which he denied. This claim led to his erroneous deportation to El Salvador where he faced mistreatment.

Garcia's lawyers are amending a civil lawsuit against the Trump administration to block his deportation while he awaits trial on human smuggling charges in Tennessee. They seek to include his allegations of torture and wrongful deportation in the filing to prevent his removal again.

He is currently in federal custody in Tennessee facing human smuggling charges and the Department of Justice is considering deportation to a third country.

Due to severe mistreatment and inadequate nutrition in CECOT prison, Kilmar Abrego Garcia lost over 30 pounds during nearly three months of wrongful imprisonment.

History

See how this story has evolved over time.

  • 11d
    Al Jazeera logo
    CNN logo
    Washington Examiner logo
    6 articles
  • 12d
    Associated Press logo
    CBS News logo
    The Guardian logo
    4 articles