President Trump's Ukraine Peace Plan Faces Widespread Condemnation from US Lawmakers and European Allies
President Trump's 28-point peace plan for Ukraine, developed with the Kremlin without Kyiv's input, proposes controversial terms like territorial concessions and military cuts, drawing strong criticism from US senators and European leaders for rewarding Russian aggression.
Overview
- President Trump's administration, in collaboration with the Kremlin, developed a 28-point peace plan for Ukraine without involving Ukrainian officials, drawing immediate criticism from US and European lawmakers.
- The controversial proposal includes demands for Ukraine to withdraw troops from Donetsk, cut its military, renounce NATO membership, and potentially cede territories like Donbas and Crimea.
- US senators, including Angus King and Jeanne Shaheen, and European leaders widely condemn the plan, arguing it rewards Russian aggression and concedes to Moscow's demands, which Ukrainian President Zelenskyy rejects.
- While Russian President Putin welcomed the proposal as a potential basis for peace, critics express concern that limiting Ukraine's armed forces could leave the nation vulnerable to future attacks.
- Despite Trump's push for Ukraine to accept the plan by next week, and Washington considering cutting aid, security officials from several nations are scheduled to meet in Geneva to strengthen the peace initiative.
Report issue
Read both sides in 5 minutes each day
Analysis
Center-leaning sources frame this story by consistently highlighting the widespread opposition and perceived flaws of Trump's Ukraine peace plan. They prioritize and extensively detail criticisms from Ukrainian officials, bipartisan U.S. lawmakers, and European leaders, often leading with these negative reactions. This editorial choice emphasizes the plan's contentious nature and its perceived concessions to Russia.
"U.S. senators critical of President Donald Trump’s approach to ending the Russia-Ukraine war said Saturday that the peace plan he is pushing Kyiv to accept would only reward Moscow for its aggression and send a message to other leaders who have threatened their neighbors."
ABC News"The proposal includes a security guarantee with a commitment that U.S. and European allies to Ukraine would treat any future attack on Ukraine as an attack on the broader trans-Atlantic community, a U.S. official told NBC News, with few additional details about what the commitment would entail."
NBC News"The plan is definitely a nonstarter, but I don’t rule out that it might be part of Trump’s game."
Chicago Tribune"The peace plan he is pushing Kyiv to accept would only reward Moscow for its aggression and send a message to other leaders who have threatened their neighbors."
Chicago Tribune"The plan would achieve most of Putin’s goals."
Chicago Tribune"The plan does not offer a genuine path to lasting peace, but instead, demands the surrender and capitulation of Ukraine to Russian aggression."
CBS News"The statement said: "We believe therefore that the draft is a basis which will require additional work.""
BBC News"We anticipate constructive work and are ready to advance as swiftly as possible to achieve a real peace."
ABC News"The 28-point peace plan proposed by the U.S. for Ukraine is a basis that "requires additional work," Western leaders gathered at the G20 summit in South Africa said."
CBS News"The plan could amount to a dangerous capitulation for Ukraine, which has previously rejected plans that would require recognizing Russia's illegal annexations of the entire eastern Donetsk region and Crimea."
NBC News"Ukraine would be expected to make steep concessions, too."
USA TODAYArticles (23)
Center (11)
FAQ
The plan reportedly requires Ukraine to cede territories such as Donbas and Crimea, withdraw troops from Donetsk, cut its military, renounce NATO membership, and accept limited security guarantees without Western troops.
US senators and European leaders have widely condemned the plan, arguing it rewards Russian aggression and concedes to Moscow's demands, which they believe undermines Ukraine's sovereignty and security.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has rejected the plan, stating it forces Ukraine to choose between loss of dignity or risking the loss of a key partner, and has expressed concerns about territorial concessions and military restrictions.
Russian President Vladimir Putin acknowledged receipt of the plan and stated it could form the basis for a final peace settlement, but noted that it is not being discussed substantively with Russia, likely due to Ukraine's opposition.
If Ukraine accepts the plan, it would lose significant territory and military autonomy, potentially leaving it vulnerable to future Russian aggression, while also losing the support of key Western allies if it refuses.
History
- 5d10 articles
- 6d
3 articles