Pano News
Subscribe
Jack Smith Probe Fight· Day 2

Sen. Blackburn Sues Jack Smith

The Tennessee Republican alleges the former special counsel improperly obtained her phone records.

September 30, 2026 · Updated Sep 30, 4:42pm ET

33%

Left · 4

25%

Center · 3

42%

Right · 5

Pano counted 12 articles from 11 outlets: 33% left-leaning, 25% center and 42% right-leaning. Pano rates the coverage Balanced.

What happened

Sen. Marsha Blackburn sued former special counsel Jack Smith and the Justice Department in federal court in Tennessee over subpoenas for her phone toll records. She says the subpoenas violated the Constitution by sweeping in legislative work and political contacts. The lawsuit follows Smith’s Senate Judiciary testimony a day earlier, after Republicans pressed him over records gathered in his Trump-related probe. Blackburn also argues Smith was unlawfully appointed because he was not nominated by the president or confirmed by the Senate. She seeks $1, return or destruction of the records, and an order destroying any legislative materials. Sen. Bill Hagerty separately asked Tennessee officials to seek Smith’s disbarment. The court fight now begins.

How the left told it

Left-leaning coverage cast the suit as an effort to turn Smith’s subpoenas into an abuse-of-power story, not neutral oversight. Raw Story pointed to the Verizon subpoena as the lawsuit’s “central grievance”. Joe.My.God. called Blackburn’s suit “performative MAGA grandstanding,” and Raw Story also emphasized doubts about Republicans’ legal theories and Arctic Frost claims.

How the right told it

Right-leaning coverage framed Blackburn’s case as a constitutional challenge to Smith’s authority and the secrecy around the subpoena. Newsmax quoted Blackburn’s argument that Smith lacked lawful power because his appointment was not Senate-confirmed, and also highlighted her claim that secret collection of legislative phone records violated her constitutional rights. The Gateway Pundit advanced the broader lawfare frame, saying Smith and the Biden Justice Department targeted Trump and Republicans.

Jack Smith Probe Fight

Storyline →
  1. Sep 30Sen. Blackburn Sues Jack Smith (this story)Balanced
  2. Sep 30Eric Schmitt Defends Hearing ClaimMostly Left
  3. Sep 29Jack Smith Defends ProbesLeans Left

Topics in this story