John Brennan Lawsuit Dismissed

A federal judge rejected John Brennan’s bid to preserve DOJ probe records.

Balanced

3 left4 center3 right

Updated Oct 15, 7:38pm ET

Every side, every morning

A free recap of the day’s biggest stories and how each side covered them.

What happened

U.S. District Judge Jia Cobb dismissed former CIA Director John Brennan’s lawsuit seeking an order requiring the Justice Department to preserve investigation records. Brennan has not been criminally charged, and Cobb ruled that a possible indictment and later loss of records were too uncertain to give him standing now. Brennan sued in July, saying he may need the records to challenge any future prosecution as selective or vindictive. He alleges political retaliation over his opposition to Trump and his role in the 2016 Russia-election assessment; Trump has called for his prosecution. Brennan’s lawyers said preservation was needed, while the Justice Department called the request speculative. Whether Brennan will be charged remains unclear.

How each side covered it

From the left

Left-leaning outlets framed the dismissal as a procedural loss while keeping Brennan’s political-retaliation claim central. HuffPost cited Brennan saying the case reflected a “political vendetta” against a perceived Trump adversary. MS NOW lingered on Cobb’s view that the allegations were troubling but too speculative, and on Brennan’s concerns about deleted communications.

From the right

Right-leaning outlets emphasized that Brennan’s request asked courts to act before concrete harm was shown. The Gateway Pundit said Cobb found Brennan had not shown records were being destroyed. It also tied the fight to Brennan’s claim of vindictive prosecution and to the continuing Spygate inquiry over alleged false statements.

Headlines

  1. 188articles
  2. 264articles
  3. 358articles
  4. 443articles
  5. 539articles
  6. 638articles