Abdul El-Sayed Disavows Muslim Brotherhood

The Michigan Senate candidate also rejected claims of dual loyalty during a heated town hall.

Balanced

10 left2 center8 right

Updated Oct 18, 8:59pm ET

Both sides, every morning

The day’s biggest stories and how each side covered them. Free.

What happened

Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed disavowed the Muslim Brotherhood at a Caro, Michigan, town hall after an attendee asked whether he would do so. He then challenged the attendee about why he had asked. The exchange followed scrutiny of El-Sayed’s family after old posts by his half-sister described their mother as active in the Muslim Brotherhood in the 1970s. El-Sayed is the Democratic nominee against former Republican congressman Mike Rogers for the seat of retiring Sen. Gary Peters. El-Sayed said the question implied his Muslim faith created “dual loyalties.” Rogers said the issue was ideology and alleged family connections, while El-Sayed’s campaign called that racist and untrue. Election Day is Nov. 3.

How each side covered it

From the left

Left-leaning outlets framed the exchange as a test of anti-Muslim suspicion, with emphasis on El-Sayed defending his loyalty to the Constitution. CNN focused on his pushback against an implied claim of “dual loyalty”. The Guardian centered Jan Crawford’s deleted praise for the questioner and her apology under CBS standards. Daily Beast highlighted The Handbasket’s identification of the questioner as a former Republican staffer.

From the right

Right-leaning outlets framed the controversy as a legitimate question about ideology and associations, while noting El-Sayed’s religious-bias defense. Fox News cited Rogers saying concerns involved ideology and alleged family support for the Muslim Brotherhood, and described El-Sayed invoking Kennedy-era questions about Catholic loyalty. It also made the press part of the story, including Crawford’s withdrawn criticism.

Headlines