Lindsay Clancy Returns To Court
A judge will weigh defense motions after Clancy's murder trial ended with a deadlocked jury.
September 29, 2026 · Updated Sep 29, 12:02pm ET
21%
Left · 5
21%
Center · 5
58%
Right · 14
Pano counted 24 articles from 17 outlets: 21% left-leaning, 21% center and 58% right-leaning. Pano rates the coverage Leans Right.
What happened
Lindsay Clancy returned to Plymouth Superior Court as her lawyers pressed Judge William Sullivan to end the murder case after a deadlocked trial. Defense lawyer Kevin Reddington asked for a not-guilty finding under Rule 25, arguing the evidence did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Clancy admits she killed her three children, but her defense says postpartum psychosis made her not criminally responsible. Prosecutors say she acted deliberately and planned the killings. Reddington also sought dismissal on double-jeopardy grounds and asked for an inquiry into the lone holdout juror. Sullivan took the Rule 25 motion under advisement and set another hearing for November 2.
How the left told it
Left-leaning accounts framed the hearing as a defense effort to stop a second trial, with criminal responsibility at the center rather than only the deaths. The Guardian emphasized that posture, while Rolling Stone focused on Reddington’s attack on the prosecution’s proof as speculative. CNN lingered on the holdout juror’s role and the privacy fight around him.
How the right told it
Right-leaning accounts put the holdout juror and the next procedural stakes in the foreground, giving the hearing a more pivotal frame. Fox News centered the juror who resisted the rest of the panel and drew praise for refocusing attention on the children. The New York Post highlighted the defense’s bid as a striking challenge to the prosecution’s proof.
Lindsay Clancy Murder Case
Part of the storyline · Storyline →- Oct 15Lindsay Clancy Juror Speaks OutBalanced
- Oct 1Lindsay Clancy Motion DeniedBalanced
- Sep 29Lindsay Clancy Returns To Court (this story)Leans Right
- Sep 22Lindsay Clancy Lawyer Seeks ProbeBalanced
- Sep 20Patrick Clancy Shares GriefMostly Left

Rolling Stone

New York Post
CNN

FOX News


Daily Mail
MEDIAite
CBS News
Just the News

The Daily Wire
The Post Millennial
RedState
The Gateway Pundit